PLYMOUTH — On May 23, 2026, at approximately 12:15 AM, Plymouth Police units were dispatched by Marshall County
911 to the intersection of Pierce and Gilmore Streets for a fight reportedly involving approximately twenty people.
While en route, dispatch advised that there were guns and pipes involved and that a vehicle was getting its windows smashed out. Dispatch reported that there were up to seven individuals with handguns. Upon arrival, officers located several individuals who had been involved in the altercation, along with unspent rounds in the roadway. In speaking with witnesses and victims, it was alleged by two individuals that they had been pistol-whipped and had a handgun put to the back of their head. They advised that some of the suspects ran into the residence at 200 Pierce St.
Officers attempted to make contact with the individuals inside the residence, with no response. A search warrant was obtained, and the Indiana State Police Emergency Response Team was contacted to assist in serving the warrant. It was alleged that there were up to 10 individuals in the residence along with an unknown number of weapons. While waiting for the ERT team, the front door opened, and one subject exited while two individuals were observed running to the back of the residence.
Officers then entered the residence and located five individuals in a bedroom in the rear of the residence. The individuals would not comply with the officer’s commands, and a Marshall Sheriff’s Dept K-9 was deployed. Two individuals who resisted were bitten by the K-9. All five individuals were then detained and later taken into custody. Several handguns were also located inside the residence.
Four individuals were initially arrested and transported to the St Joseph Hospital ER for treatment and jail clearance. Some of the initial charges include Intimidation with a Deadly Weapon, Battery, Public Intoxication, Minor Consuming, Obstruction of Justice, Criminal Mischief, and Resisting Law Enforcement.
The Plymouth Police Department will continue to investigate the incident to determine if any further charges need to be filed by the Prosecutor’s Office. Further charges may occur after the investigation is complete and forwarded to the Marshall County Prosecutors’ Office for review.
Those initially arrested on varying charges are:
•Austin C Price, 19, Plymouth, IN
•Elijah K Waggoner, 21 Plymouth, IN
•Kiley E Pitts, 21 Plymouth, IN
•Amro Y Yasin, 20 Plymouth, IN
Suspects are considered innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.
